Top 5 Best Dog Treat Recipes with Pumpkin and Peanut Butter

Best Dog Treat Recipes with Pumpkin and Peanut Butter | Healthy & Tasty Rewards for Your Pup

This is a little, holy thing in my kitchen when the dust of the flour is floating in sunlight, and my dog is settled on the floor just below me, and his tail is ticking like a little metronome. I lay my reach into the bowl, and swab a sticky spoonful, and see that countenance illuminated. Varying recipes of dog treat preparations that require the use of pumpkin and peanut butter is not solely about baking it is a little ritual of love and care. It is during mornings after the thunderstorm, during the quiet training after work, and during the celebration of small victories (such as sit and stay and please don’t chew my slippers).

I will go to the extent of demonstrating how to prepare safe, dog ally dishes, suggestions on ways in which one can make such recipes more doable, storage recommendations as well as ways in which one can adjust such recipes into picky dogs or dogs with food allergies. The culinary context in each of the recipes is healthier and more affordable food products, as well as the outdoor and irresistible trio of pumpkin and peanut butter.

What is the reason behind peanut butter and pumpkin?

Pumpkin is a mild superstar to dog digestion: with a great amount of fiber, few calories, and containing vitamin A and potassium. When it is applied in the proper manner it is capable of forming loose stool or assist with constipation. Peanut butter is a source of protein and healthy fats and a taste that is better loved by dogs but will always use xylitol-free peanut butter (xylitol is lethal to dogs). They are all the ingredients of the perfect neutral foundation that is simple to customise to reach grain free diets or elder dogs or training-sized bites.

These are versatile pumpkin and peanut butter recipes of dog treats: Biscuit-like crunchy treats, cheese, no bake bites, frozen summer pops, as well as grain-free ones can be made using just two healthy ingredients.

Safety first (non-negotiables)

It should be used in pure canned pumpkin and not pumpkin pie contents which contains sugar and spices that are dangerous to dogs.

The peanut butter must be xylitol free. Read labels carefully.

The introduction of new treats should be postponed and allergies and digestion discomfort should be monitored.

Peanut butter should only be added to the food of dogs with pancreatitis or other special dietary restrictions, only with the advice of your vet.

Avoid raisins, grapes, chocolate and Macadamianuts as well as artificial sweeteners.

Top 6 Dog Treat Recipes with Pumpkin and Peanut Butter

Recipe 1 — Classic Pumpkin & Peanut Butter Biscuits (Crunchy)

Ingredients

• 1 cup canned pumpkin (pure pumpkin)

• 1/2 cup peanut butter (xylitol-free)

• 2 cups whole wheat flour (substitute oat flour or rice flour if needed)

• 1 egg (optional, helps bind)

Instructions

1. Preheat oven to 350°F (175°C).

2. Mix pumpkin and peanut butter until smooth.

3. Add egg (if using). Gradually stir in flour until a firm dough forms.

4. Roll to 1/4” thickness and cut into shapes or roll into small balls and flatten.

5. Bake 20–25 minutes until golden and firm.

6. Cool completely.

These dog treat recipes with pumpkin and peanut butter make sturdy biscuits that travel well — perfect for walks or gifting to neighbors with pups.

Recipe 2 — Soft Training Treats (Small & Chewy)

Ingredients

• 1/2 cup pumpkin

• 1/4 cup peanut butter (xylitol-free)

• 1 cup oat flour

• 1–2 tbsp water (only if needed)

Instructions

1. Stir pumpkin and peanut butter together.

2. Add oat flour and mix until soft dough forms.

3. Pinch off pea-sized pieces, flatten slightly.

4. Bake at 325°F (160°C) for 12–15 minutes until set but still soft.

5. Cool and use for training.

Small, soft treats keep calorie load low while boosting attention — a big help when teaching new cues.

Recipe 3 — No-Bake Peanut Butter Pumpkin Bites

Ingredients

• 1 cup rolled oats

• 1/2 cup pumpkin

• 1/3 cup peanut butter (xylitol-free)

• 1 tbsp honey (optional — don’t use if your dog is diabetic)

Instructions

1. Combine all ingredients until well mixed.

2. Form small balls and press gently.

3. Refrigerate until firm (about 30–60 minutes).

4. Store in fridge up to one week.

No-bake dog treat recipes with pumpkin and peanut butter are perfect for hot days or when you want a quick, oven-free option.

Recipe 4 — Grain-Free Pumpkin & Peanut Butter Bites

Ingredients

• 1 cup canned pumpkin

• 1/2 cup peanut butter (xylitol-free)

• 1 1/2 cups almond flour

• 1 egg

Instructions

1. Combine ingredients in a bowl until dough forms.

2. Scoop small portions, flatten slightly.

3. Bake 12–15 minutes at 350°F (175°C).

4. Cool completely.

This is great for pups with grain sensitivities. Always introduce almond flour gradually and watch for reactions.

Recipe 5 — Pumpkin & Peanut Butter Frozen Pops (Summer Treats)

Ingredients

• 1 cup plain unsweetened yogurt

• 1/2 cup pumpkin

• 1/4 cup peanut butter (xylitol-free)

Instructions

1. Blend ingredients until smooth.

2. Pour into silicone molds or ice cube trays.

3. Freeze until solid.

These dog treat recipes with pumpkin and peanut butter are a hydrating, cooling reward on hot afternoons.

Recipe 6 — Dental Crunchers (To Help Chew & Clean)

Ingredients

• 1 cup pumpkin

• 1/2 cup peanut butter (xylitol-free)

• 2 cups rice flour

• 1/4 cup ground barley or flaxseed (optional)

Instructions

1. Mix all into a stiff dough.

2. Roll and cut into long, thin shapes.

3. Bake at 350°F (175°C) for 25–30 minutes until very dry and crunchy.

4. Let cool slowly to maximize crunch.

Crunchy textures can help scrape plaque mechanically — not a substitute for brushing, but a useful supplement.

Top 5 Best Dog Treat Recipes with Pumpkin and Peanut Butter (Amazon USA picks)

Here are five of my favourite treats that fit the bill. I’ve pulled out features, pros, cons—all with a dog-lover’s heart.

1. Buddy Budder Pumpkin Pup Squeeze Packs

(100 % Natural Dog Peanut Butter, Healthy Dog Treats, Made in USA)

• Description: These are convenient squeeze-packs of peanut butter with pumpkin flavour built in. The “Pumpkin Pup” version lists ingredients like peanuts, pumpkin, cinnamon, honey.

• Features:

  • Ready-to-serve squeeze format—no baking required.

  • Made in USA, with no unnecessary additives (according to the listing).

  • Multipurpose: lick mat, kong filler, treat, training reward.

• Pros:

  • Very convenient for busy pet-parents.

  • Strong flavour appeal for most dogs (peanut butter + pumpkin = win).

  • Good for travel/training because easy to carry.

• Cons:

  • Because it’s peanut-butter rich, calorie count may be higher—so portion control needed.

  • Squeeze-format might be messier than biscuits.

Call to Action: Check the latest price on Amazon.

2. Chippin Peanut Butter Dog Biscuits – Pumpkin & Cricket Protein

• Description: Crunchy biscuits that combine peanut butter and pumpkin, plus cricket protein as a novel sustainable ingredient.

• Features:

  • Fibre-rich ingredients like flaxseed, oats.

  • Suitable for dogs with sensitive stomachs; hypoallergenic emphasis.

  • Made in USA by a small business.

• Pros:

  • Crunchy texture supports chew satisfaction.

  • Unique protein source (cricket) may appeal for eco-conscious pet owners.

  • Good for sensitive dogs.

• Cons:

  • Some dogs may take time to warm up to “novel” protein like cricket.

  • Crunchy might be harder for senior dogs with weaker teeth.

Call to Action: Check the latest price on Amazon.

3. Pumpkin Crunchers Dog Treat Peanut Butter (14 oz)

• Description: A treat that highlights pumpkin as the main ingredient, grain-wheat-corn-soy free, and infused with peanut butter flavour.

• Features:

  • Made in USA; pumpkin listed as first ingredient.

  • Free from some of the more common allergens (grain, wheat, corn, soy) per listing.

  • Large size bag for value.

• Pros:

  • Great value for frequent treat-givers.

  • Reduced fillers/less allergenic for many dogs.

• Cons:

  • With larger bag, requires proper storage to maintain freshness.

  • While peanut butter flavour is present, might not be as strong as pure peanut butter treats.

Call to Action: Check the latest price on Amazon.

4. Jiminy’s Crunchy Original Peanut Butter & Pumpkin Dog Treat

• Description: Eco-friendly dog biscuits combining peanut butter and pumpkin, using insect-protein (cricket) for sustainability.

• Features:

  • Low‐calorie option.

  • Prebiotic/hypoallergenic friendly.

  • Sustainable protein alternative (insect) – unusual in dog-treat world.

• Pros:

  • Good choice for dogs requiring low calorie rewards.

  • Strong flavour appeal with peanut butter & pumpkin.

  • A positive pick for eco-conscious pet-parents.

• Cons:

  • Some dogs/caregivers may be hesitant about insect protein (though safe).

  • Crunchy texture again maybe less ideal for older dogs.

Call to Action: Check the latest price on Amazon.

5. Buddy Budder Pumpkin Pup + Superberry Peanut Butter Set

(2 × 17 oz Jars, Made in USA)

• Description: A value set of large jars; includes the pumpkin version along with a berry variant. Emphasis again on peanut butter base + pumpkin.

• Features:

  • Large jars = good for homes with multiple dogs or frequent treat giving.

  • Peanut butter base with pumpkin flavour plus added berry variant gives flexibility.

• Pros:

  • High-value set, good for frequent use.

  • The variety lets you switch flavours (pumpkin vs berry) to keep things interesting.

• Cons:

  • Large size may mean risk of spoilage if not stored properly.

  • More peanut butter content means higher treat calories; good monitoring required.

Call to Action: Check the latest price on Amazon.

Also Read: Homemade Dog Food Supplements | Healthy & Natural Nutrition Guide

Tips for texture, size, and baking success

Crunchy vs chewy: Roll dough thin and baking time will be more and make it thicker and reduce bake time so that it becomes chew.

Small Dogs: Cut small circles or take bite of an inch size to control calories.

Puppies and elderly: Softer treats (fewer bake time) and smaller amounts.

Sticky dough works better chilled and then it can be cut in shape.

Change flours: Oat, rice or almond flour is a good substitution in case of an allergy.

Numerous pet owners question how to nail the most ideal texture and these dog treat recipes using pumpkin and peanut butter provide well to minor changes: the addition of a little more flour to make it firm, a sprinkling of water to make it chewy.

Flavor add-ins (safe options)

Mashed banana (small amounts)

Unsweetened applesauce

Unsweetened yogurt (in moderation) that is plain.

Turmeric (small pinch – check with vet to dose)

Cooked sweet potato (pureed)

Avoid nutmeg, excessive amounts of cinnamon and salt, honey in puppies, grapes, raisins, chocolate and fake sweeteners.

Storage & shelf life

Refrigerator: not longer than 1 week (soft/no-bake and those that contain yogurt).

Freezer: no more than 3 months (bake in batches and freeze).

Countertop (dry Biscuits): in airtight: 3-7 days.

Label and date your batches because you know when they are fresh. Freezing Desserts Frozen desserts may be thawed in the refrigerator or at room temperature; a slight thawing can bring out aroma and make desserts all the more enticing.

Foodstuff and calories — maintain your puppy at a comfortable size.

There should be treats of [?]10% calories daily. Two small cookies or a few training bites should be enough in the case of a 20 lb (9 kg) dog. When in doubt, weigh treats and find an approximation of re calories of ingredients or request your vet to have a target.

These pumpkin and peanut butter dog treat recipes are not only rich but also satisfying, they only require control in the portions particularly by dogs that tend to gain weights.

Areas of common troubleshooting.

Dough too sticky? Gradually add more flour and allow to be chilled (15-30 minutes).

Salesman just above, but sticky underneath. Reduce the amount of oven temperature and cook more.

Bitter/odd flavor? Check the label of the peanut butter to make sure that there is an added sweet or oil separation, it is better to stir and use natural brands.

Dog won’t eat? To test put a small piece into a warmer or put the crumbs over normal food.

Suppliers of ingredients and quality.

Select pumpkin cans, peanut butter, and flours that are BPA free, peanut butter that has only one ingredient (peanuts, salt only- no xylitol), and organic flours. Better ingredient quality will result in fewer additives, more prominent labels, and this makes these dog treat recipes with pumpkin and peanut butter more hazardous and nutritional.

Special needs variations.

Low-fat: Replace peanut butter with lower-calorie and more pumpkin, as well as oat flour.

Senior dogs: Use less bake time in order to make softer treats, use no honey, be small.

Quickly allergy-free: Substitute the flour with rice or oat; peanut allergies should be suspected (considering sunflower seed butter (xylitol-free) after a conversation with the vet).

Emotional moments: the importance of baking.

We do not simply give them a biscuit but we make a memory. The scent of pumpkin, the slow swirling of peanut butter, finding a potential pet at your feet as the oven heats beating dog treat recipes with pumpkin and peanut butter makes you feel better, lessens the stress, and solidifies that human-dog relationship. It is the type of care that manifests itself through little acts over and over again.

FAQ

Q: Is pumpkin safe every day?
A: It is safe, and even useful in the digestive system, in small portions of plain pumpkin. Do not overuse and ask your vet in case of GI chronic condition in your dog.

Q: Is it possible to use natural peanut butter?
A: Yes, but it has to be natural peanut butter without xylitol. Check labels carefully.

Q: I have an allergic dog– what do I do?
A: Replace flours (oat, rice, almond), trial new ingredients one at a time, and also consult your vet.

Q: What is the life of homemade treats?
A: See storage section above – one week in the fridge, a maximum of three months in the freezer on most recipes.

Weekly treat plan (sample)

Monday: 2 traditional biscuits during the walk.

Tuesday: Training session -10 soft training treats.

Wednesday: Bites with nothing in them as evening enrichment.

Thursday: 1 frozen pop + outdoor games.

Friday: Chewy tooth as tooth-stuff enrichment toy stuffing in.

Saturday: A special bite is an alternative to our Sunday bite, but it’s grain-free.

Sunday: rest day– no candy and some extra cuddles.

A plan such as it maintains variety and control, and allows your pup to enjoy these pumpkin and peanut butter dog treat recipes but not to over-indulge in calories.

Conclusions

Nothing is as good as being able to see the little whirl of the tail when your pup smells of something special. The following recipes of dog treats using pumpkin and peanut butter are aimed at being simple, safe, and loving, they are variable to most diets and can be baked in batches. Ready to make recipes card-able, get a personalized calorie guide based on the weight and age of your dog, and have gluten-free alternatives? Enter the weight, age of your dog and any food allergies and I will create you a plan.

You can always bake well, you can always give well and you can always enjoy those brown, believing eyes of your dog, after the crumbs are consumed long after you have forgotten all about them.